downtoearth-subscribe

At crossroads

This year, Ralph Nader faces one of the stiffest challenges of his career -and the visible possibility of a setback -since the failed attempt to get the Congress to establish a Consumer Protection Agency. The setback could stem from an issue known as the 'tort reform', which seeks to restrict punitive damages awarded by juries for wrongs in civil I}ability cases, like those which hold that consumer products have dangerous defects. In some cases, the awards could total no more than us $250,000. Even if President Clinton vetoes the tort measure, as he may possibly do, the Republican majority could override his veto, as it did with a recently enacted law to limit stockholders' rights to file fraud suits.

The tort reform, believes Nader , could be a serious blow to the us consumer, because big awards have introduced the element of safety into many products: chain saws are now equipped with safety guards, cars now have rear-seat safety belts, farm tractors have antirollover bars and children's sleeping wear is treated with flame retardants.

"Nader is at something of a crossroads," says Philip Duncan, editor of the Congressional Quarterly book, Politics in America, "To the degree that damage awards are limited, Nader loses a big weapon in his war against business interests."

However, Nader is undaunted by such possible flops. "In the citizens movement, you've got to be in a mode where you're never defeated," he says. This attitude should stand him in good stead as he gets ready to take on the rough and tumble of US politics.

Related Content